Best Public Schools in Etters, PA

The city of Etters, Pennsylvania is home to two elementary schools, Red Mill Elementary School and Newberry Elementary School, both part of the West Shore School District. Based on the available data, Red Mill Elementary School emerges as the standout school, consistently outperforming Newberry Elementary and the district/state averages across various academic measures.

Red Mill Elementary School boasts significantly higher test scores in PSSA Math, Science, and English Language Arts compared to Newberry Elementary. In the 2023-2024 school year, 66.1% of Red Mill students were proficient or better in PSSA Math, compared to 46.2% at Newberry Elementary and 47.3% for the district. Additionally, Red Mill Elementary maintains a 4-star rating from SchoolDigger, while Newberry Elementary is rated 2 stars. Red Mill also ranks in the top 27% of Pennsylvania elementary schools, while Newberry is in the bottom 36%.

Despite Newberry Elementary spending slightly more per student ($18,422) than Red Mill Elementary ($17,997), the data suggests that Red Mill is more efficiently allocating its resources to support student learning. The higher free/reduced lunch rate at Newberry Elementary (53.82%) compared to Red Mill (37.7%) may indicate a lower socioeconomic status of the student population, which could be a contributing factor to the school's lower academic performance. These findings highlight the importance of factors beyond just funding and resources, such as school culture, leadership, and teaching quality, in driving student outcomes.