Best Public Schools in Mastic Beach, NY

The city of Mastic Beach, New York is home to three schools that are part of the William Floyd Union Free School District: one elementary school, one middle school, and one high school. While the district serves a predominantly economically disadvantaged student population, the data reveals a pattern of underperformance across the schools, with most lagging behind state averages on key metrics like test scores and graduation rates.

William Floyd High School, the largest school in the district with over 3,000 students, stands out for its relatively high 4-year graduation rate of 84.3%, though this is still below the state average. The school also performs well on certain Regents exams, with over 80% proficiency in Algebra II, English Language Arts, and Physics. However, it struggles in other areas, such as Algebra I and Living Environment, where proficiency rates are below 30%. In contrast, Tangier Smith Elementary School shows stronger performance on 5th grade state assessments, with over 50% proficiency in English Language Arts and Math.

Across the district, students perform below state averages on many Regents and state assessments, particularly in Math and Science. William Paca Middle School and Tangier Smith Elementary School struggle the most, with proficiency rates often 10-20 percentage points below state averages. This suggests systemic challenges that may need to be addressed at the district level, potentially through identifying and replicating the practices and strategies that contribute to the relative successes seen at Tangier Smith Elementary.